I think some form of a probation system would be a good idea. It would be a great way to keep the users of your server in check and could be used as an alternative to banishment. What I propose is that players who are being unruly or have been caught on the wrong side of a ban appeal should be marked as being on probation, maybe a as a new rank or something, so other players know that he may be bad news. I also propose that players on probation be stripped of certain privileges as punishment for their misconduct and that probation only be put on a player for a limited time.
Earthly Kingdoms